Courtney Love vs Her Lawyer – A Twitter Outburst that led to the first Twitter Libel Case to actually go to Trial

Courtney Love is being sued by her former lawyer, for a tweet, via micro blogging site Twitter, which claimed that her lawyer, Rhonda Holmes had  been ‘bought off’, as a result of refusing to act for Ms. Love, in bringing a claim relating to fraud, in respect of her late husband Kurt’s Cobain’s estate. A tweet that Ms Holmes claims is plainly an example of online defamation. You cannot blame Ms. Holmes for taking this action, after all, the normal and ordinary meaning of this phrase would make the public at large think that she was dishonest and lacked integrity – there are not much worse things that you could say to a lawyer, if you wanted to attack them.

In the US, unlike here in England, their defamation rules, including matters pertaining to online defamation are different. In simple terms, an ISP cannot be sued, given that they are merely a third party (under the Communication Decency Act) and also the statements complained of are given much more scrutiny as a result of the protections afforded by the First Amendment. Matters presented as fact are not protected, but statements presented as opinion are generally protected. In this case, there was no doubt in the Judge’s mind that Ms. Love was presenting her tweet in respect of Ms Holmes as fact, which is completely understandable given that Ms. Love was her client, and therefore was given what appeared to be ‘factual’ information about the attorney/client relationship.  Ms. Love’s lawyers attempted to say that the internet creates a different set of rules and that what may previously have been considered facts were in fact conjecture and speculation – and that Ms Love was not stating facts, but merely giving opinion, and therefore the matter could not have been considered online defamation. This was an argument that was out rightly rejected by the Judge – therefore giving leave for the matter to march on for trial. 

Had this case been brought in England, in the High Court, then there is no doubt that it would be taken very seriously by the Court, and  if we at Pinder Reaux were acting for Ms. Holmes we would be pursuing Ms Love ultra – aggressively for the alleged online defamation published by Ms Love against Ms Holmes.  

John Spyrou
Head of Internet and Media Law

Business Services News

Read Next


What people say

"We shall, no doubt, be engaging you again soon"

"The matter was concluded very successfully and I’d like to thank John and Wilson again for their helpful and highly professional work earlier this year."

Alex Bailey, Trichromic LLP'

"Great Source of Support"

"You have essentially achieved what we had set out to do. Thank you for all of your assistance in this matter. Throughout this ordeal, you have been a great source of support."

Mary Anne Poutanen, Canada

"I could not have chosen a better firm to represent me."

"You provided the key essentials (and more) for client satisfaction. I am extremely pleased with the services provided by your company and the legal team provided for me. To also turnaround my situation making it a positive outcome, I could not have chosen a better firm to represent me."

Marvyn Smith, London

"I would recomend this service to anyone who has a legal matter"

"I'm so glad I had this advice before my CMD. I was very much prepared and think my company (whom I'm taking to a tribunal) were shocked at my knowledge. I would recommend this service to anyone who has a legal matter."

Jacqueline Stevenson, Bristol

"Can’t wait for another session!"

"John Spyrou kindly offered to provide our publishing firm with an update on libel and defamation law. Those who attended - a mix of veteran editors and those new to the world of journalism - all said how practical and useful they found the training – and now can’t wait for another session!"

Paul Snell, Redactive Media Group

"Highly recommended"

"Alana & Pinder Reaux’s level of service has been exceptionally high. Always keen to help out with the work in an efficient manner. Highly recommended."

Trading Point of Financial Instruments UK Ltd

"Fast and Reliable"

"Fast and reliable notary service for notarisation/legalisation of College reports for foreign office and embassies."

Student Services Department, CATS College London

"One step ahead of the opposition"

"'John Spyrou has the ability to pre-empty arguments and see issues before they arise, thereby allowing him to be one step ahead of the opposition’"

Christopher Bovey, Angelbird Technologies GmbH